Sign In
RecruiterRank
Browse by IndustryBrowse by CityGuides
RecruiterRank

Find and compare the best recruiting agencies for your hiring needs.

Browse

  • By Industry
  • By City
  • Guides

For Agencies

  • Get Listed
  • Sign In

Company

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Our Methodology
© 2026 RecruiterRank. All rights reserved.

Top Insurance Recruiters and Headhunters

Placing underwriters, actuaries, and claims professionals who price risk accurately and keep policyholders protected.

268 insurance recruiting agencies and headhunters ranked by performance and reviews

251
Midwest Consulting Group, Inc.
4.0(6 reviews)

Founded in 1994 and locally owned, we are a full-service IT staffing firm with offices in Overland Park, Kansas and Dallas, Texas, serving clients across more than 28 states from government agencies to private enterprises. Our services include contract consulting, direct hire placement, contingent labor, project outsourcing, and management solutions across specializations such as cloud architecture, database development, DevOps, software development, and cybersecurity. As a GSA Schedule 70 contract holder, we are authorized to provide IT expertise to federal, state, and local government agencies, and we have built our reputation on straightforward business practices that deliver lasting client satisfaction.

252
SourcePoint Staffing
4.0(31 reviews)

SourcePoint Staffing is your jobs agency. Our recruiters each specialize in a specific segment of the job market. Whether you have just entered the job force, are looking to change careers, or have had a long job history, we're here to find your ideal job. We specialize in: Administrative Support Banking Call Center Customer Service Management Inside Sales Outside Sales Purchasing Property Management Supply Chain & Logistics General Labor Warehousing Shipping Material Handling Assembly Machine Operation Machinists

253
Infinia Search
4.0(10 reviews)

Hi, we're Infinia Search! We're a relationship driven search firm that proves that talent, ambition, curiosity, and an infinite work ethic creates exponential results for our clients and candidates. We take our jobs serious, and how we interact with each and every candidate. We might not be able to find a job for everyone, but we want to make sure we provide the best experience possible during that process. Our mission is simple. Make the right matches between candidates and employers by taking the time to understand them both.

254
leadstack
4.0(17 reviews)

One of the nation's fastest-growing, certified minority-owned staffing firms, we deliver strategic and scalable workforce solutions across Information Technology, Life Sciences, and Marketing and Creative Services. Headquartered in South San Francisco, our AI-driven recruitment technology enhances every step of the talent acquisition process—from sourcing and resume screening to skills assessments and candidate engagement. Recognized multiple times as a Best Staffing Firm to Work For and a Fastest Growing Staffing Firm by Staffing Industry Analysts, we serve clients across a wide range of industry verticals through both Staff Augmentation and Statement of Work engagement models.

255
Quad656
4.0(9 reviews)

Since 2001, we have been recruiting and placing senior talent across accounting, finance, HR, legal, sales, marketing, analytics, IT, engineering, and insurance. As the largest tenured recruiting firm in the Philadelphia region, our team of seasoned consultants brings 38 years of combined experience to every search. We serve clients through direct hire, temporary, and contract engagements, and our women-owned firm is proud to have grown to 75 team members across our Wayne, PA and Mount Laurel, NJ offices, matching exceptional candidates with top employers throughout the Delaware Valley and beyond.

256
The Jacobson Group
4.0(6 reviews)

For more than 50 years, our firm has served as the leading talent partner exclusively dedicated to the insurance industry. Since our founding in 1971, we have built a proprietary database of more than 500,000 insurance professionals nationwide and achieved placement rates nearly double the industry average with a 97% client satisfaction rate. Our comprehensive service offerings span executive search, professional recruiting, temporary staffing, staff augmentation, interim expert placement, and MSP program fulfillment. We serve carriers, agencies, and brokerages across health, life, and property and casualty verticals, bringing unmatched market depth and specialized knowledge to every search engagement.

257
Pareto
3.9(79 reviews)

At our New York office (140 Broadway #3630), we recruit and train candidates (sales graduates) and hire senior sales executives for a range of organizations, from SME level to global blue-chip companies. As a leading staffing agency, our team covers businesses not only in New York but across the US. Our team is dedicated to finding the best sales opportunities for candidates throughout the United States. We accommodate weekly graduate assessment days over zoom and at our New York office.

258
WAHVE LLC
3.9(12 reviews)

Launched in 2010, we created an entirely new staffing model for the insurance industry by connecting agencies, brokers, carriers, wholesalers, MGAs, and TPAs with highly experienced professionals who work remotely on long-term assignments. Our talent pool—Work At Home Vintage Experts, or WAHVE—averages 25-plus years of industry experience and covers nearly every insurance function, from underwriting and claims to compliance, actuarial analysis, and customer service. We also offer Talent Acquisition Outsourcing for direct-hire roles, helping the industry retain seasoned expertise that might otherwise walk out the door.

259
NRI Staffing
3.9(27 reviews)

Providing world-class staffing services since 1967, we are a Washington, D.C.-based regional firm serving commercial and government employers across the greater D.C., Northern Virginia, and Maryland markets. Our distinct teams of specialists handle permanent placement, temp-to-hire, temporary help services, and contract staffing for administrative, accounting, healthcare, legal, property management, and professional roles. We believe the right fit goes beyond matching skills to job descriptions, which is why our proven recruitment process combines industry expertise with cutting-edge sourcing technology. With offices in D.C., Virginia, and Rockville, we rigorously screen every candidate for skill, experience, and cultural alignment.

260
trak group
3.9(75 reviews)

trak group is a second-generation recruiting firm, established in 1994 and based in Cincinnati. Serving the Greater Cincinnati region, our mission is simple: to build our community by connecting people. We partner with companies and job seekers across industries, including Accounting & Finance, Shared Services (admin, sales, marketing, business), Manufacturing, Engineering, Supply Chain, and IT. With a personalized, tailored approach, we offer contract, contract-to-hire, and direct hire solutions that help people and organizations thrive.

261
Tailored Management
3.7(206 reviews)

Tailored Management is a global staffing and workforce solutions firm dedicated to connecting top-tier talent with leading organizations across diverse industries. With over 40 years of experience, we specialize in providing customized staffing services, including contingent labor solutions, direct placement, recruitment process outsourcing (RPO), and vendor-on-premise (VOP) programs . Tailored Management Our innovative Centralized Recruiting Hub model enables us to deliver consistent, high-quality staffing solutions worldwide, effectively minimizing costs and enhancing communication . By leveraging advanced technology and a collaborative approach, we ensure efficient and compliant hiring processes tailored to each client's unique needs.

262
Barrington Staffing
3.6(33 reviews)

Since 1982 we have made employment matches servicing communities throughout the San Fernando Valley, Burbank & Glendale, West Los Angeles, the Conejo and Simi Valleys, and the Santa Clarita Valley. As one of the leading staffing agencies in Los Angeles and Ventura Counties, our team of recruiting experts is dedicated to your success. Temporary Temporary To Staff Employer Hires Direct

263
Ark Temporary Staffing
3.6(195 reviews)

We specialize in delivering temporary and permanent placement services across diverse industry sectors, serving small businesses, corporate clients, and government agencies throughout the Greater Atlanta area since 2005. Our expertise spans administrative and clerical roles, data processing, light industrial, warehouse, customer service, insurance, and general services, with a proven track record working with both private sector companies and federal government contracts. What sets us apart is our unwavering focus on client productivity combined with our commitment to diversity consulting and world-class service. We maintain a comprehensive database of qualified candidates from varied backgrounds, and we enhance every placement with meticulous back-office processes that ensure efficiency for employers while creating an enjoyable work experience for candidates.

264
Zing
3.5(43 reviews)

Zing Professional is a professional recruitment firm that specializes in sourcing and delivering people with imagination, perspective, and -- dare we say it -- Zing! As a national staffing firm, we have access to databases and networks that other firms can't offer. And, they help us do our job: to help you find the right fit ... a customized solution to match your talent needs. We help you find people with hard and soft skills, personal and professional attributes, talent and ability, smarts and imagination. And, our efforts deliver results.

265
InnoSource
3.4(153 reviews)

InnoSource is built on the premise that through a well-designed process and passion, we can change the way people think about staffing firms. We're serious about acquiring and retaining the highest quality talent. So we offer a benefits package that is among the best in the industry. It's one of the reasons our primary source of candidates is the employed workforce. They are excited and eager for this career opportunity, not resigned to it. Highly qualified and passionate individuals in a well-matched environment create success.

266
Strategic Staffing
3.4(27 reviews)

Since 1990, we have grown into a global IT consulting and business services corporation with operations in 49 states and 22 countries. As a certified woman-owned enterprise, we deliver staff augmentation, total workforce management, outsourced solutions, and direct hire recruiting with deep expertise in financial services, energy, healthcare, insurance, telecommunications, and retail. We have reported consistent growth and profit every year since our founding, while donating more than $44 million to charitable organizations worldwide. Our commitment to diversity extends to veterans through our SkillBridge internship program, helping service members transition to rewarding civilian careers.

267
EXPERIS
3.2(50 reviews)

Experis is a global leader in employment services, creating and delivering services that enable job seekers and employers to win in the changing world of work. We offer a range of services, including permanent, temporary and temp-to-perm placement; employee assessment and selection; training; and consulting. As a trailblazer in the industry for more than 40 years, we have the experience and expertise to help you build your workforce in the way that makes the most sense and achieves the best business results - whether you need two project managers or 200 developers, at one site or 50 locations across the country. Experis is part of ManpowerGroup, the world leader in innovative workforce solutions.

268
Compunnel, Inc.
3.2(182 reviews)

With over three decades of experience since our founding in 1994, we deliver AI-powered talent acquisition, staffing, and workforce solutions that connect organizations with exceptional talent across healthcare, BFSI, retail, manufacturing, and technology sectors. Operating from coast to coast in the U.S. through 30+ delivery centers and across global hubs in Canada, India, and the UK, we serve 200+ clients — including 23% of the Fortune 500. Our specialized recruiters source talent from AI architects and cloud engineers to healthcare professionals and allied staff, delivering candidates others can't find. We combine data-driven talent acquisition services and scalable workforce solutions with comprehensive digital transformation and cybersecurity capabilities, ensuring every placement supports measurable business outcomes with full compliance built in.

← Prev1…91011Next →